Why Your Astrologer is Not a Gemologist (And Why That’s Okay!)

Astrologers recommend gemstones based on your birth chart. Gemologists ensure the stone you wear is real and effective. Learn why both roles matter and how to get the best results from your planetary remedy.

Your astrologer and your gemologist play different roles.
Both are important.
But they’re not the same.

Let’s break it down.

Astrology is About Planets and Timing

Your astrologer studies planetary movements and cosmic patterns.
They read your birth chart and identify which planet needs to be strengthened or pacified.

  • A good astrologer studies for years under a guru or school.
  • They understand houses, nakshatras, dashas, and transits.
  • They prescribe a gemstone based on your individual horoscope—not trends.

For example:
You might be told to wear a yellow sapphire to strengthen Jupiter.

That’s the prescription.

Gemology is About the Gem Itself

Your gemologist makes sure the gem you’re buying is real, natural, and worth the price.
They don’t read charts.
They read crystals.

  • Gemology is a science-based field.
  • It involves microscopes, refractometers, and lab reports.
  • It takes years of training to identify, grade, and certify stones.

Let’s say you’ve been prescribed a blue sapphire.
The gemologist will help you find a real one—natural, untreated, and of correct weight and origin.

That’s the medicine.

Think of It Like This

Your astrologer is like a doctor writing a prescription.
Your gemologist is like a pharmacist who fills it accurately.
You need both to get the result you’re hoping for.

Why Mixing the Two Can Be Risky

Some astrologers sell gems directly.
That’s convenient, but it creates a conflict.

  • How do you know the stone is genuine?
  • Is the price fair?
  • Has it been treated or filled with glass?

Would you trust a doctor to sell you the medicine without showing the label?

Ask yourself:
Are you getting a planetary remedy or a business deal?

A Real-World Example

One client was told to wear an emerald.
He bought a bright green stone from his astrologer.
But it turned out to be green glass—worth ₹100.

The astrologer may have meant well.
But they lacked gemological training.

We replaced it with a certified Colombian emerald.
The result? His confidence and peace of mind returned.

How to Make a Better Choice

When your astrologer gives you a gem recommendation:

  • Get a lab-tested gem from a qualified gemologist.
  • Ask for a certificate of authenticity.
  • Ensure the weight, clarity, and origin match your astrologer’s advice.
  • Never buy just by color. Two identical-looking stones can be worlds apart.

Your Next Step

Respect both experts for their knowledge.
Don’t expect one to do the other’s job.

Your astrologer understands your stars.
Your gemologist understands your stone.

Let each do what they do best.